On the positives list is the world of Rapture and the characters inside it. I doubt you'll find anyone who doesn't really feel the same way. The art-deco design, licensed oldies tunes, and whimsical retro kitsch combine to make an extremely unique environment, especially for a genre dominated with spaceship corridors and military bases. Rapture really did feel like a genuine world that was in decay. You could see traces of the old gilded exterior and the 'ghost replays' (mirages of now-dead citizens at the moment of tragedy) contributed a sort of mystical sense of nostalgia. Though I'd never seen Rapture as it originally was, I felt sincerely sorry it had collapsed. The locales you journey through - old theaters, dance halls, metros, apartments, markets, science labs - are dotted with this generation's favorite storytelling device: audio logs. I loved these as well. You could listen to them while you were playing the game instead of being forced to sit on a menu. Each was cleverly written and delivered with convincing emotion. If you play the game I suggest you pay attention to them - not only do they sometimes have passwords and key combos you'll need for precious ammo and EVE (more on that later), they're the primary plot device. If you ignore them you're not going to have as good a grasp of Rapture and what happened to it.
Enjoying the plot and art is going to be a bit of a problem, though, because Bioshock brings the tension of survival horror resource management back to the FPS with a vengeance. This isn't a game where you'll have more clips than you can carry and ammo restocks between cutscenes. I swear, if I ever had more than twenty antipersonnel bullets for my pistol then I don't remember it. Having to constantly scrounge ammo and goodies is a bit of chore and makes the game feel longer than it really is, but it definitely adds to the suspense and keeps you on your toes. You have to learn how to use your plasmid powers (like psychic or biotic powers from other games) efficiently and combine them with your weapons for max damage, and maxing your money and ADAM is a must. If you buy the right upgrades, keep your eyes peeled for loot, hack everything, and learn what weapons hurt what enemies then you'll be fine. It just demanded more thought from me than I'm used to delivering.
Between the agile enemies and ever-present security systems I died quite a bit, and at first it was frustrating. Then I became acquainted with the Vita Chambers, perhaps Bioshock's most bizarre design choice. When you die, you are reanimated inside a nearby Vita Chamber with all of your health and ammo and gear intact. Furthermore, the Vita Chambers aren't like checkpoints or game reload points - the game continues as if you'd never died, which means that all enemies have whatever health they had when you died. So the harshest of fights could essentially be taken care of without a single bullet or drop of plasmid juice by whacking things with your hammer until you die, then coming back and whittling them down some more. With Vita Chambers always so close to the action and so few ways for enemies to heal themselves, the unmotivated gamer is going to find Bioshock to be a pretty easy thing to slog through. The final boss was a joke, too.
The Vita Chambers pretty much stole all the tension from the 'only one bullet left' resource management. That was my main thought. The story was solid, the atmosphere was impressive, and the game clearly had a lot of love put into it. I'm interested to see 2K's take on things without Irrational's creative vision, so Bioshock 2 is on the radar. But more than that I want to see how Irrational itself deals with these issues. So bring on Bioshock Infinite, although I think we have more than just a little wait. In the meantime, I recommend you try the first bit of Bioshock if you haven't played it yet. I'm positive the thinking man will find some of the mechanics to their liking and pretty much everyone should get pleasure from the non-combat side of things.
